NavArch Handbook
Chapter 1 / Section 1.8
Thickness measurements (UTM) in surveys, inclining-test readings, speed-trial runs, weight audits and tank soundings are all repeated measurements with scatter. The engineer must summarise them, decide which readings are outliers, estimate the uncertainty of derived quantities, and fit straight lines.
(sample standard deviation, divisor ) describes the scatter of single readings; the uncertainty of the mean. For a normal distribution about 68 % of readings lie within , 95 % within , 99.7 % within .
A reading more than from the mean (or failing Chauvenet's criterion: probability of occurrence × n < 0.5) is suspect: re-measure or document the reason for discarding it. Never discard inclining-test pendulum readings silently; the IS Code requires the plot of all readings.
Slope and intercept as in Section 1.6. Coefficient of determination:
Standard error of the slope: . For the inclining test, the slope is and is the uncertainty of GM.
For a result with independent uncertainties :
For products and quotients the relative uncertainties add in quadrature: . For sums and differences the absolute uncertainties add in quadrature. The difference of two nearly equal quantities () inherits the absolute uncertainties of both — which is why a ±3 cm uncertainty in KG is large when GM is 0.70 m.
Report for each plate group: number of readings, mean thickness, minimum, standard deviation, and the percentage below the renewal thickness. Class rules set the renewal criterion on the minimum reading, not the mean (DNV Rules Pt.7 — survey requirements; IACS UR Z10 series) — statistics describe the condition, the rule decides on the extreme.
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Reading i | as measured | |
| Number of readings | - |
Result unit as measured
Result unit as measured
Result unit as measured
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Corrected sums of squares and products | - |
Result unit -
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Fitted slope | - |
Result unit unit of b
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Standard uncertainty of input i | as input | |
| Standard uncertainty of the result | as result |
Result unit as result
Result unit -
| k | Fraction of readings within ± k s | Fraction outside |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 68.27 % | 31.7 % |
| 1.645 | 90.0 % | 10.0 % |
| 1.960 | 95.0 % | 5.0 % |
| 2 | 95.45 % | 4.55 % |
| 2.576 | 99.0 % | 1.0 % |
| 3 | 99.73 % | 0.27 % |
| Measurement | Typical standard uncertainty | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Draught reading at marks (calm water) | ± 5–10 mm | Larger with waves; read both sides |
| Water density by hydrometer | ± 0.001–0.002 t/m³ | Temperature correction |
| Inclining pendulum deflection (3 m pendulum) | ± 1 mm | → tan φ ± 0.0003 |
| Inclining weight mass (certified) | ± 0.1–0.5 % | Weighbridge certificate |
| UTM plate thickness | ± 0.1 mm | Calibrated gauge, clean surface |
| Lightship displacement from inclining | ± 0.5–1 % | Draughts + density + deductions |
| Lightship KG from inclining | ± 2–5 cm | Dominated by KM accuracy and free surfaces |
| Speed over ground (GNSS, trial run) | ± 0.05 kn | Average of double runs |
Worked example
Problem
Eight weight shifts on the example vessel ( t) gave the heeling moments M [t·m] and mean pendulum readings tan φ: (0, 0.0005), (60, 0.0128), (120, 0.0252), (60, 0.0126), (0, −0.0003), (−60, −0.0121), (−120, −0.0249), (−60, −0.0124). Fit M = a + b tan φ, report R², and derive GM.
Solution
; , ; , .
; .
; ; .
The intercept is negligible (no initial list or restraint), R² is excellent (no free-surface non-linearity), and GM agrees with Example 5.2. Standard error of the slope: t·m, i.e. GM ± 0.004 m from the regression alone (the real uncertainty is dominated by KM and the displacement).
Worked example
Problem
with relative uncertainties: ρ 0.1 %, L 0.1 %, B 0.2 %, T 1.0 % (draught ± 5 cm on 5.5 m), 1.0 % (from the hydrostatics at that draught). Find the relative uncertainty of Δ and the absolute value for Δ = 6314 t.
Solution
All exponents are 1:
t. The draught reading and the hull-form coefficient dominate; improving the length measurement would change nothing. This is the order of accuracy of a draught survey, and the reason deadweight surveys for cargo quantity need careful draught and density readings.
Worked example
Problem
Six readings on a 10 mm deck plate [mm]: 9.8, 9.9, 10.1, 9.7, 10.0, 9.9. Report mean, standard deviation and minimum; compare with a renewal thickness of 8.0 mm (20 % diminution).
Solution
mm. Deviations: −0.1, 0, +0.2, −0.2, +0.1, 0; ; mm. Minimum 9.7 mm. Mean diminution 1.0 %, minimum reading 3.0 % below nominal — far above the 8.0 mm renewal limit. Report: 'n = 6, mean 9.90 mm, s = 0.14 mm, min 9.7 mm, 0 readings below renewal thickness'.
Renewal is decided on measured minimum thickness vs rule allowable diminution; confirm the edition in force.