Back to section

NavArch Handbook

Chapter 2 / Section 2.12

Allowable stresses and safety factors in rule-based design

Two formats

  • Working (allowable) stress design: the computed stress under the characteristic (unfactored) load must not exceed an allowable stress σallow=η σy\sigma_{\text{allow}} = \eta\,\sigma_yσallow​=ησy​ (or σy/γ\sigma_y/\gammaσy​/γ). Classification society hull rules, DNV-ST-0378 (lifting appliances) and most equipment standards use this format. The usage factor η\etaη (or permissible stress coefficient) depends on the load case and on what is checked.
  • Partial-factor (LRFD) design: factored loads γfF\gamma_f Fγf​F against factored resistance R/γmR/\gamma_mR/γm​. Eurocodes (EN 1993: γM0=1.0\gamma_{M0} = 1.0γM0​=1.0, γM1=1.0\gamma_{M1} = 1.0γM1​=1.0, γM2=1.25\gamma_{M2} = 1.25γM2​=1.25) and DNV offshore standards (DNV-OS-C101: γm=1.15\gamma_m = 1.15γm​=1.15 for steel yield, load factors 1.3/0.7 ULS-a and 1.0/1.3 ULS-b) use this format. Never mix the two formats in one check.

What the allowable depends on

  1. Load case: operating (frequent) vs survival/extreme (rare) vs accidental — the rarer the load, the higher the permitted fraction of yield (typically ≈ 0.6–0.7 operating, 0.8–0.9 extreme, up to 1.0 accidental/ALS). Lifting: in-service vs stowed vs overload test.
  2. Stress type: hull girder nominal (175/k MPa in IACS UR S11), local bending of stiffeners and plates (rule coefficients), shear (τallow≈0.58 σallow\tau_{\text{allow}} \approx 0.58\,\sigma_{\text{allow}}τallow​≈0.58σallow​ or an explicit value), von Mises in FE (coarse mesh vs fine mesh — different allowables because the fine mesh captures peaks), weld throat.
  3. Material factor kkk (DNV, IACS): 1.0 for 235 MPa, 0.78 for 315, 0.72 for 355, 0.68 for 390 — the allowable is scaled by 1/k1/k1/k, i.e. not proportionally to yield (Section 3.2).
  4. Consequence and redundancy: primary members vs secondary; single load path (pedestal, lifting lug) vs redundant.
  5. Dynamic amplification: already in the load (DAF, hoisting factor ψ, motion accelerations) — not in the allowable; do not apply both a dynamic factor and a reduced allowable unless the standard says so.

Where to find the numbers

The exact permissible stresses are in the governing document and change between editions. Indicative ranges are given in the table only to recognise an implausible result; take the design value from the standard in force and cite it in the calculation.

Structure of a rule-based check (report format)

  1. Load case definition (standard, section, load factors / dynamic factors).
  2. Loads (magnitude, point of application, direction) with source.
  3. Section properties (net or gross — state) and material (σy\sigma_yσy​, kkk).
  4. Stresses (axial, bending, shear, torsion, combined).
  5. Allowable from the standard (document, section, load case).
  6. Unity check UC=σ/σallow≤1.0UC = \sigma/\sigma_{\text{allow}} \le 1.0UC=σ/σallow​≤1.0; buckling and fatigue checks where applicable.
  7. Conclusion with the governing element and the margin.

Common errors

  • Comparing a fine-mesh FE peak stress with a nominal-stress allowable (or the reverse).
  • Using gross scantlings where the rule requires net (or vice versa).
  • Applying the operating-case allowable to a survival load, or doubling dynamic factors.
  • Scaling the allowable linearly with yield for high-strength steel instead of using 1/k1/k1/k.
  • Omitting the buckling check for members in compression that pass the yield check.
  • Treating the crane maker's "SWL" as the design load without the hoisting/dynamic factor of the structural standard.

Formulas

01Allowable stress (working stress design)
σallow=η σy=σyγ,UC=σσallow≤1.0\sigma_{\text{allow}} = \eta\,\sigma_y = \frac{\sigma_y}{\gamma}, \qquad UC = \frac{\sigma}{\sigma_{\text{allow}}} \le 1.0σallow​=ησy​=γσy​​,UC=σallow​σ​≤1.0
SymbolDescriptionUnit
η\etaηUsage factor (permissible stress coefficient) for the load case-
γ\gammaγSafety factor = 1/η-
σy\sigma_yσy​Specified minimum yield stress (ReH)MPa

Result unit MPa

02Material factor (DNV / IACS) and scaled allowable
σallow=σallow,235k,k=1.00 (235), 0.78 (315), 0.72 (355), 0.68 (390)\sigma_{\text{allow}} = \frac{\sigma_{\text{allow},235}}{k}, \qquad k = 1.00\ (235),\ 0.78\ (315),\ 0.72\ (355),\ 0.68\ (390)σallow​=kσallow,235​​,k=1.00 (235), 0.78 (315), 0.72 (355), 0.68 (390)
SymbolDescriptionUnit
kkkMaterial factor-

Result unit MPa

e.g. hull girder 175/k: 175 (mild), 224 (AH32), 243 (AH36) MPa.

03Partial factor format (LRFD)
∑iγf,i Si ≤ Rkγm\sum_i \gamma_{f,i}\,S_i \ \le\ \frac{R_k}{\gamma_m}i∑​γf,i​Si​ ≤ γm​Rk​​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
γf,i\gamma_{f,i}γf,i​Load factor for load i-
SiS_iSi​Characteristic load effectas applicable
RkR_kRk​Characteristic resistanceas applicable
γm\gamma_mγm​Material/resistance factor (DNV-OS-C101: 1.15; EC3 γ_M0 = 1.0)-

Result unit -

04Allowable shear from allowable normal stress (von Mises)
τallow=σallow3=0.577 σallow\tau_{\text{allow}} = \frac{\sigma_{\text{allow}}}{\sqrt 3} = 0.577\,\sigma_{\text{allow}}τallow​=3​σallow​​=0.577σallow​

Result unit MPa

05Design load for lifting appliances (general form)
Fd=ψ (SWL+mrigging) g+self-weight+motion and wind loadsF_d = \psi\,(SWL + m_{\text{rigging}})\,g + \text{self-weight} + \text{motion and wind loads}Fd​=ψ(SWL+mrigging​)g+self-weight+motion and wind loads
SymbolDescriptionUnit
ψ\psiψHoisting (dynamic) factor from the lifting standard (typically 1.1–1.3 harbour/offshore in-service; higher for subsea or offboard lifts)-
SWLSWLSWLSafe working load (mass)t

Result unit kN

Take ψ, the load combinations and the allowables from DNV-ST-0378 (or the applicable standard) — never from this general form alone.

Tables

Indicative usage factors / allowable stresses in common standards (orientation only — take design values from the standard in force)

CheckStandardIndicative allowableComment
Hull girder bending, nominalIACS UR S11 / DNV Pt.3 Ch.5175/k MPa (≈ 0.75 σ_y for mild steel)Shear 110/k MPa
Local bending of plating under lateral pressureDNV Pt.3 Ch.6Rule coefficient ≈ 0.8–1.0 × σ_y/k in the thickness formula (includes membrane effect)Formula-embedded
Stiffener bending (local + hull girder)DNV Pt.3 Ch.6Rule coefficient; combined ≈ 0.8–0.9 σ_y/kFormula-embedded
Primary members, coarse-mesh FE von MisesDNV Pt.3 Ch.7 / CG-0127≈ 0.9 σ_y/k (static + dynamic), lower for static aloneElement-size dependent
Fine-mesh FE (50 × 50 mm) peak von MisesDNV CG-0127≈ 1.5–1.7 × coarse allowable (local yielding accepted)Mesh-size specific
Equipment foundations, operatingDNV-ST-0378 Sec. 4 (lifting appliances)σ_e ≤ σ_y/γ with γ ≈ 1.5 (operating, in-service)Confirm load case table
Equipment foundations, survival/stowed/accidentalDNV-ST-0378γ ≈ 1.1–1.33 (rarer cases)Confirm
Steel members, EurocodeEN 1993-1-1Factored loads vs f_y/γ_M0 (γ_M0 = 1.0)LRFD format
Offshore steel, DNV LRFDDNV-OS-C101γ_f 1.3 (permanent/variable, ULS-a) × S ≤ R/1.15LRFD format
BoltsEN 1993-1-8F_v,Rd = 0.6 f_ub A_s/1.25Section 2.2
Fillet weldsEN 1993-1-8 / class rulesf_u/(√3 β_w γ_M2); class: throat = factor × plate thicknessSection 8.3
Source: IACS UR S11; DNV Rules for Classification — Ships Pt.3 Ch.5–7; DNV-CG-0127; DNV-ST-0378; DNV-OS-C101; EN 1993-1-1/-1-8. All values indicative — editions change; cite the exact clause in the design file.

Examples

#01

Crane pedestal foundation check (working stress format)

Worked example

Problem

A deck crane on the example vessel: SWL 10 t at 12.0 m outreach; crane self-weight 15 t with CoG 3.0 m from the slew axis; hoisting (dynamic) factor ψ = 1.3 on the hook load (assumed design basis — confirm with DNV-ST-0378 for the actual crane class); ship heel 5° producing a horizontal component of the vertical loads at the pedestal top, 3.0 m above the deck; slewing torque 150 kN·m. Pedestal: tube Ø 1200 × 20 mm, mild steel σ_y = 235 MPa. Check the pedestal shell at the deck connection with an indicative usage factor η = 0.85 (operating). Then list the further checks required.

Solution

Loads. Vertical: Fv=(10×1.3+15)×9.81=28.0×9.81=274.7F_v = (10 \times 1.3 + 15) \times 9.81 = 28.0 \times 9.81 = 274.7Fv​=(10×1.3+15)×9.81=28.0×9.81=274.7 kN.

Overturning moment at the pedestal top: M0=(10×1.3×12.0+15×3.0)×9.81=(156+45)×9.81=1972M_0 = (10 \times 1.3 \times 12.0 + 15 \times 3.0) \times 9.81 = (156 + 45) \times 9.81 = 1972M0​=(10×1.3×12.0+15×3.0)×9.81=(156+45)×9.81=1972 kN·m.

Horizontal from 5° heel: Fh=274.7sin⁡5°=23.9F_h = 274.7 \sin 5° = 23.9Fh​=274.7sin5°=23.9 kN; additional moment at the deck: 23.9×3.0=7223.9 \times 3.0 = 7223.9×3.0=72 kN·m. Total M=2044M = 2044M=2044 kN·m. Torque T=150T = 150T=150 kN·m.

Section (mean radius 590 mm, t = 20 mm): A=2π×590×20=74 140A = 2\pi \times 590 \times 20 = 74\,140A=2π×590×20=74140 mm²; I=πrm3t=π×5903×20=1.290×1010I = \pi r_m^3 t = \pi \times 590^3 \times 20 = 1.290 \times 10^{10}I=πrm3​t=π×5903×20=1.290×1010 mm⁴; W=I/600=2.151×107W = I/600 = 2.151 \times 10^7W=I/600=2.151×107 mm³; Am=π×5902=1.094×106A_m = \pi \times 590^2 = 1.094 \times 10^6Am​=π×5902=1.094×106 mm².

Stresses at the extreme compression fibre. σN=274 700/74 140=3.7\sigma_N = 274\,700/74\,140 = 3.7σN​=274700/74140=3.7 MPa; σM=2044×106/2.151×107=95.0\sigma_M = 2044 \times 10^6/2.151 \times 10^7 = 95.0σM​=2044×106/2.151×107=95.0 MPa; σ=98.7\sigma = 98.7σ=98.7 MPa (compression). Torsional shear τT=150×106/(2×1.094×106×20)=3.4\tau_T = 150 \times 10^6/(2 \times 1.094 \times 10^6 \times 20) = 3.4τT​=150×106/(2×1.094×106×20)=3.4 MPa; transverse shear at the extreme fibre ≈ 0 (maximum 2Fh/A=0.62F_h/A = 0.62Fh​/A=0.6 MPa at the neutral axis).

σe=98.72+3×3.42=9742+35=98.9 MPa\sigma_e = \sqrt{98.7^2 + 3 \times 3.4^2} = \sqrt{9742 + 35} = 98.9\ \text{MPa}σe​=98.72+3×3.42​=9742+35​=98.9 MPa

Allowable and unity check. σallow=0.85×235=200\sigma_{\text{allow}} = 0.85 \times 235 = 200σallow​=0.85×235=200 MPa (indicative). UC=98.9/200=0.49UC = 98.9/200 = 0.49UC=98.9/200=0.49 ✓.

Further checks required before this foundation is accepted:

  1. Load cases per DNV-ST-0378 (in-service with vessel motions and wind; stowed in survival sea state; overload test 1.25 SWL) with the standard's own factors and allowables — the 5° heel used here is a placeholder for the motion criteria.
  2. Shell buckling of the pedestal (DNV-RP-C202): r/t=29.5r/t = 29.5r/t=29.5, classical σcr=0.605×206 000×20/590=4225\sigma_{cr} = 0.605 \times 206\,000 \times 20/590 = 4225σcr​=0.605×206000×20/590=4225 MPa — far above yield, so local buckling is not critical here, but the RP-C202 check must be documented.
  3. Deck structure under the pedestal: insert plate thickness, under-deck girders/brackets carrying M=2044M = 2044M=2044 kN·m as a force couple (≈M/D=1700\approx M/D = 1700≈M/D=1700 kN), weld at the pedestal foot (throat for the shell stress of 99 MPa and the shear flow), and the slew-ring bolt pretension per the crane maker.
  4. Fatigue of the pedestal-to-deck weld and bracket toes (Section 2.11, Example 1) — usually the governing check for crane foundations in service.
  5. FE model per DNV-CG-0127 if the deck structure is not a simple beam system (Section 7.9, 7.11).

References

DNV-ST-0378 Standard for offshore and platform lifting appliancesClause Sec. 4 (Design loads and load cases), Sec. 5–6 (Structural strength, allowable stresses, foundations)Mandatory

For cranes and their pedestals/foundations under DNV certification; confirm edition in force.

IACS Unified Requirement S11 Longitudinal strength standardClause S11.4 (Permissible stresses: 175/k bending, 110/k shear)Mandatory
DNV Rules for Classification — Ships, Pt.3 Ch.5 (Hull girder strength), Ch.6 (Hull local scantling), Ch.7 (Finite element analysis), Ch.8 (Buckling)Clause Permissible stress coefficients and acceptance criteriaMandatory

Confirm section numbering in the edition in force.

DNV-CG-0127 Finite element analysisClause Acceptance criteria for coarse and fine meshRecommended
DNV-OS-C101 Design of offshore steel structures, general — LRFD methodClause Sec. 2 (Design principles — load and material factors)Mandatory

Offshore units; given here for comparison of formats.

EN 1993-1-1:2005 Eurocode 3 — Part 1-1Clause 6.1 (Partial factors γ_M)Recommended
NavArch Handbook · Chapter 2 · printed on —