Back to section

NavArch Handbook

Chapter 5 / Section 5.12

Damage stability fundamentals: lost buoyancy vs added weight, permeability

Two equivalent methods

When a compartment is opened to the sea, the final equilibrium can be computed in two ways:

Added weight (added mass) method — the flood water is treated as a mass added to the ship. Displacement increases; KGKGKG changes; the free surface of the flood water is a free-surface effect; KMKMKM is taken at the new displacement. The ship sinks and trims until the new Δ\DeltaΔ equals the buoyancy of the intact hull at the new waterline including the damaged compartment up to the new waterline — an iteration is needed because the flood water depends on the final waterline.

Lost buoyancy (constant displacement) method — the damaged compartment is considered no longer part of the ship. Displacement and KGKGKG are unchanged; the ship loses the buoyancy of the flooded volume and the waterplane area of the compartment; the remaining intact volume must sink until the lost buoyancy is regained. KBKBKB, BMBMBM and KMKMKM are those of the damaged hull (reduced waterplane). No free surface correction (the water is not "on board").

Both give the same final draughts, trim and heel. The intermediate quantities (GMGMGM, KGKGKG) differ, so never mix the two methods. Classification and SOLAS software use the lost buoyancy method; hand calculations of a box barge are easiest by lost buoyancy.

Lost buoyancy procedure (box-shaped compartment, no trim)

  1. Volume lost: v=μ l b Tv = \mu\,l\,b\,Tv=μlbT (compartment length lll, breadth bbb, permeability μ\muμ).
  2. Intact waterplane after damage: A′=AWP−μ l bA' = A_{WP} - \mu\,l\,bA′=AWP​−μlb.
  3. Sinkage: δT=v/A′\delta T = v / A'δT=v/A′.
  4. New KBKBKB, new ITI_TIT​ of the intact waterplane (subtract the compartment's second moment, including its own parallel-axis term if off-centre), new BM=IT′/∇BM = I_T'/\nablaBM=IT′​/∇, KM′=KB′+BM′KM' = KB' + BM'KM′=KB′+BM′, GM′=KM′−KGGM' = KM' - KGGM′=KM′−KG (KG unchanged).
  5. Off-centre compartment: heeling moment from the shift of the centre of buoyancy; heel tan⁡θ=v y/(∇ GM′)\tan\theta = v\,y/(\nabla\,GM')tanθ=vy/(∇GM′) (small angles).

Permeability

The fraction of a compartment's volume that can be occupied by flood water. SOLAS Ch. II-1 Reg. 7-3 values are tabulated below; for probabilistic damage stability the cargo space permeabilities depend on the draught considered (dsd_sds​, dpd_pdp​, dld_ldl​).

Regulatory framework (overview)

  • SOLAS Ch. II-1, Part B-1 — probabilistic damage stability (attained index A≥A \geA≥ required index RRR) for passenger ships and cargo ships ≥ 80 m (as amended 2009, 2020).
  • Deterministic damage stability still applies to specific types: ICLL 1988 Reg. 27 (type A and reduced-freeboard type B ships), MARPOL Annex I (tankers), IBC/IGC Codes, SPS Code 2008 (special purpose ships), MODU Code, and OSV Guidelines (Res. MSC.235(82) as amended by MSC.335(90)) — which is the route for most offshore supply vessels.
  • Fishing vessels — Torremolinos/Cape Town Agreement requires damage stability only for vessels ≥ 100 m (Ch. III Reg. 2(5)) unless the Administration requires more; NMA regulations may add requirements.
  • Survival criteria after damage (deterministic, typical): final waterline below the margin line / openings; final heel ≤ 15°–17° (SPS: 15°), residual GM≥0.05GM \ge 0.05GM≥0.05 m, residual GZ range ≥ 15°–20° with area ≥ 0.015 m·rad and GZmax⁡≥0.10GZ_{\max} \ge 0.10GZmax​≥0.10 m (passenger-ship type criteria; OSV Guidelines Ch. 3) — always take the exact figures from the governing instrument.

Formulas

01Lost buoyancy: sinkage after flooding (box compartment, no trim)
δT=μ l b TAWP−μ l b\delta T = \frac{\mu\, l\, b\, T}{A_{WP} - \mu\, l\, b}δT=AWP​−μlbμlbT​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
μ\muμPermeability-
l,bl, bl,bLength and breadth of the flooded compartmentm
TTTInitial draughtm
AWPA_{WP}AWP​Intact waterplane area before damagem^2

Result unit m

02Lost buoyancy: new transverse BM
BM′=IT−μ(l b312+l b y2)∇BM' = \frac{I_T - \mu\left(\dfrac{l\,b^3}{12} + l\,b\,y^2\right)}{\nabla}BM′=∇IT​−μ(12lb3​+lby2)​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
yyyTransverse distance of compartment centroid from centrelinem
∇\nabla∇Displacement volume (unchanged)m^3

Result unit m

KG is unchanged in the lost-buoyancy method.

03Added weight: new KG
KG′=Δ KG+ρ v KgvΔ+ρ vKG' = \frac{\Delta\,KG + \rho\, v\, Kg_v}{\Delta + \rho\, v}KG′=Δ+ρvΔKG+ρvKgv​​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
vvvVolume of flood water (to the final waterline)m^3
KgvKg_vKgv​Height of the centroid of the flood waterm

Result unit m

Then subtract the free-surface effect of the flood water and use KM at Δ + ρv. Iterate on the final waterline.

04Heel after asymmetric flooding (small angles, lost buoyancy)
tan⁡θ=v y∇ GM′\tan\theta = \frac{v\, y}{\nabla\, GM'}tanθ=∇GM′vy​

Result unit deg

05Floodable length (concept)
F(x)=vreserve(x)μ Asection(x)F(x) = \frac{v_{\text{reserve}}(x)}{\mu\, A_{\text{section}}(x)}F(x)=μAsection​(x)vreserve​(x)​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
F(x)F(x)F(x)Maximum compartment length centred at x that can be flooded without immersing the margin linem

Result unit m

Conceptual; the floodable length curve is produced by the stability software (Shirokauer method in older texts).

Tables

Permeability values (SOLAS Ch. II-1, Reg. 7-3)

SpacePermeability μ\muμ
Appropriated to stores0.60
Occupied by accommodation0.95
Occupied by machinery0.85
Void spaces0.95
Intended for liquids0 or 0.95, whichever gives the more severe requirement
Dry cargo spaces (at dsd_sds​ / dpd_pdp​ / dld_ldl​)0.70 / 0.80 / 0.95
Container spaces (at dsd_sds​ / dpd_pdp​ / dld_ldl​)0.70 / 0.80 / 0.95
Ro-ro spaces (at dsd_sds​ / dpd_pdp​ / dld_ldl​)0.90 / 0.90 / 0.95
Cargo liquids (at dsd_sds​ / dpd_pdp​ / dld_ldl​)0.70 / 0.80 / 0.95
Source: SOLAS 1974 as amended, Ch. II-1, Part B-1, Reg. 7-3 (Permeability). Deterministic instruments (ICLL Reg. 27, MARPOL Annex I Reg. 28, OSV Guidelines) use 0.60 stores, 0.95 accommodation/voids, 0.85 machinery, 0.95 or 0 liquids; cargo 0.60 (ICLL type A).

Examples

#01

Flooding of a box barge — lost buoyancy method

Worked example

Problem

A box-shaped barge L=60L = 60L=60 m, B=12B = 12B=12 m floats at T=3.00T = 3.00T=3.00 m in seawater with KG=3.20KG = 3.20KG=3.20 m. A midship compartment 10 m long, full breadth, permeability 0.85, is bilged (flooded to the sea). Find the new draught and GM.

Solution

Intact: ∇=60×12×3=2160\nabla = 60 \times 12 \times 3 = 2160∇=60×12×3=2160 m³; AWP=720A_{WP} = 720AWP​=720 m²; KB=1.50KB = 1.50KB=1.50 m; IT=60×123/12=8640I_T = 60 \times 12^3/12 = 8640IT​=60×123/12=8640 m⁴; BM=4.00BM = 4.00BM=4.00 m; KM=5.50KM = 5.50KM=5.50 m; GM=2.30GM = 2.30GM=2.30 m.

Lost buoyancy: v=0.85×10×12×3=306v = 0.85 \times 10 \times 12 \times 3 = 306v=0.85×10×12×3=306 m³. Intact waterplane A′=720−0.85×120=618A' = 720 - 0.85 \times 120 = 618A′=720−0.85×120=618 m².

δT=306618=0.495 m⇒T′=3.495 m\delta T = \frac{306}{618} = 0.495\ \text{m} \Rightarrow T' = 3.495\ \text{m}δT=618306​=0.495 m⇒T′=3.495 m

New KB (box, uniform sinkage): KB′=3.495/2=1.748KB' = 3.495/2 = 1.748KB′=3.495/2=1.748 m. New IT′=8640−0.85×10×123/12=8640−1224=7416I_T' = 8640 - 0.85 \times 10 \times 12^3/12 = 8640 - 1224 = 7416IT′​=8640−0.85×10×123/12=8640−1224=7416 m⁴; BM′=7416/2160=3.433BM' = 7416/2160 = 3.433BM′=7416/2160=3.433 m (∇\nabla∇ unchanged). KM′=1.748+3.433=5.181KM' = 1.748 + 3.433 = 5.181KM′=1.748+3.433=5.181 m; GM′=5.181−3.20=1.98GM' = 5.181 - 3.20 = 1.98GM′=5.181−3.20=1.98 m.

The barge remains stable; GM has fallen from 2.30 to 1.98 m and draught increased by 0.50 m. The added-weight method gives the same draught (3.495 m) but a different intermediate GM; the two must not be compared directly.

References

SOLAS 1974 as amended, Ch. II-1, Part B-1Clause Reg. 6–7-3 (Required and attained subdivision indices, permeability)Mandatory
IMO Res. MSC.235(82) Guidelines for the design and construction of offshore supply vessels, 2006, as amended by MSC.335(90)Clause Ch. 3 (Subdivision and damage stability)Recommended

Applied as mandatory by most flag states (incl. Norway) for OSVs.

International Convention on Load Lines 1966/1988Clause Annex I, Reg. 27 (Type A and type B-60/B-100 ships — damage assumptions)Mandatory
Rawson & Tupper (2001)Clause Vol. 1, Ch. 5 (Hazards and protection — flooding)Textbook
Barrass & Derrett (2012)Clause Ch. 28–29 (Bilging and permeability)Textbook