Back to section

NavArch Handbook

Chapter 5 / Section 5.10

Heavy-lift operations and suspended weights

The suspended weight acts at the point of suspension

When a mass www is lifted by a crane or derrick, its weight acts at the head of the jib (the point of suspension), not at the hook or at the load. The instant the load leaves the quay (or the deck), the ship's KGKGKG rises as if www had been placed at the jib head height HHH:

KG′=Δ KG+w HΔ+wKG' = \frac{\Delta\,KG + w\,H}{\Delta + w}KG′=Δ+wΔKG+wH​

(if the load was already on board on deck at KgKgKg, the virtual rise is GGv=w (H−Kg)/ΔGG_v = w\,(H - Kg)/\DeltaGGv​=w(H−Kg)/Δ at constant displacement.)

Consequences

  1. Reduction of GM — can be large for a high jib and a small ship. GM′=KM′−KG′GM' = KM' - KG'GM′=KM′−KG′ with KM′KM'KM′ at the new displacement.
  2. Heeling moment from the outreach yyy of the jib head: Mh=w yM_h = w\,yMh​=wy. List tan⁡θ=w y/(Δ′ GM′)\tan\theta = w\,y/(\Delta'\,GM')tanθ=wy/(Δ′GM′); with the reduced GM′GM'GM′ the list can become excessive — anti-heeling ballast is transferred in parallel with the slew.
  3. Trim from the longitudinal position of the jib head.
  4. Dynamic effects — load swinging, crane motion and vessel motion: class rules apply a dynamic factor to the hook load for the crane structure; for stability the IS Code Part B Ch. 2.9 defines the heeling moment with the load at the maximum outreach.

IS Code 2008 Part B, Ch. 2.9 — Lifting operations (summary)

Applies to ships engaged in lifting where the lift causes a significant heel (criterion in 2.9.1). Two alternative approaches are given:

  • 2.9.2 — Residual GZ criteria: with the lifting heeling lever, the equilibrium heel shall not exceed limits set by the Administration, the residual righting lever area shall be adequate, and the residual freeboard/ downflooding limits are respected; the Code gives the methodology and leaves some limit values to the Administration. DNV implements this in Pt.3 Ch.15 / Pt.5 for crane vessels and OSV with crane notation.
  • 2.9.3 — Simplified criteria for non-counter-ballasted ships: the residual metacentric height, taking into account the lift, shall be positive and the equilibrium heel limited. A sudden loss of the load (hook failure) makes the ship roll to the opposite side; the Code requires that the ship survive this: the area under the GZ curve with the load dropped must exceed that for the load held (energy balance), and the counter-ballast remaining on board must not produce an excessive heel.

Operational practice

  • Press up or empty slack tanks before the lift; pre-ballast to the low side opposite to the expected list; limit the jib height; lift at minimum outreach; use the loading computer's "crane mode".

Formulas

01KG with a suspended load
KG′=Δ KG+w HΔ+wKG' = \frac{\Delta\, KG + w\, H}{\Delta + w}KG′=Δ+wΔKG+wH​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
wwwMass of the lifted loadt
HHHHeight of the point of suspension (jib head) above baselinem
Δ,KG\Delta, KGΔ,KGDisplacement and KG before the liftt, m

Result unit m

02Virtual rise of G when lifting a load already on deck
GGv=w (H−Kg)ΔGG_v = \frac{w\,(H - Kg)}{\Delta}GGv​=Δw(H−Kg)​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
KgKgKgHeight of the load before liftingm

Result unit m

03Heel during the lift (metacentric)
tan⁡θ=w y(Δ+w) GM′\tan\theta = \frac{w\, y}{(\Delta + w)\,GM'}tanθ=(Δ+w)GM′wy​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
yyyTransverse outreach of the jib head from centrelinem
GM′GM'GM′Metacentric height with the suspended loadm

Result unit deg

04Counter-ballast moment to limit heel to θ_max
wb yb=w y−(Δ+w) GM′tan⁡θmax⁡w_b\, y_b = w\, y - (\Delta + w)\,GM'\tan\theta_{\max}wb​yb​=wy−(Δ+w)GM′tanθmax​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
wb,ybw_b, y_bwb​,yb​Anti-heeling ballast mass and its transverse position (opposite side)t, m

Result unit t·m

Tables

Lifting operations — typical limits applied by Administrations and class (indicative)

QuantityTypical limitSource
Heel during lift (with counter-ballast)≤ 5°–10° (often 5° in operation manuals)IS Code Part B 2.9; DNV crane vessel notations
Residual GM with load suspended> 0 (simplified) / usually ≥ 0.15–0.5 m per operatorIS Code Part B 2.9.3; operator procedures
Heel after sudden load loss≤ 15° or deck-edge immersion / downfloodingIS Code Part B 2.9.2
Freeboard at the low sideNot less than a stated minimum (e.g. 0.5 m to the deck edge)Administration / operator
Dynamic hook load factor for structure1.1–1.3 (harbour/offshore) depending on crane classDNV-ST-0378 Sec. 4
Source: Compiled from IMO IS Code 2008 Part B Ch. 2.9 and DNV-ST-0378 (Standard for offshore and platform lifting appliances). Confirm the governing limits with the Administration and class for the specific vessel.

Examples

#01

GM and heel during a heavy lift

Worked example

Problem

Example vessel: Δ=6314\Delta = 6314Δ=6314 t, KGf=5.28KG_f = 5.28KGf​=5.28 m. The deck crane lifts an 80 t item from the quay with the jib head at H=25.0H = 25.0H=25.0 m above baseline and an outreach y=8.0y = 8.0y=8.0 m. KMKMKM at 6394 t is 5.95 m. Find GM′GM'GM′ during the lift and the heel without counter-ballast; then the counter-ballast required at 6.5 m off centreline to limit heel to 3°.

Solution

KG′=6314×5.28+80×25.06394=33,338+20006394=5.527 mKG' = \frac{6314 \times 5.28 + 80 \times 25.0}{6394} = \frac{33{,}338 + 2000}{6394} = 5.527\ \text{m}KG′=63946314×5.28+80×25.0​=639433,338+2000​=5.527 m GM′=5.95−5.527=0.42 m(a reduction of 0.28 m from 0.70 m)GM' = 5.95 - 5.527 = 0.42\ \text{m} \quad (\text{a reduction of } 0.28\ \text{m from } 0.70\ \text{m})GM′=5.95−5.527=0.42 m(a reduction of 0.28 m from 0.70 m)

Heel without counter-ballast:

tan⁡θ=80×8.06394×0.42=6402685=0.238⇒θ=13.4°\tan\theta = \frac{80 \times 8.0}{6394 \times 0.42} = \frac{640}{2685} = 0.238 \Rightarrow \theta = 13.4°tanθ=6394×0.4280×8.0​=2685640​=0.238⇒θ=13.4°

This exceeds the metacentric range and any operational limit; a GZ-curve calculation would be required, and the lift is not acceptable without counter-ballast.

Counter-ballast to limit heel to 3°: wb×6.5=640−6394×0.42×tan⁡3°=640−140.7=499w_b \times 6.5 = 640 - 6394 \times 0.42 \times \tan 3° = 640 - 140.7 = 499wb​×6.5=640−6394×0.42×tan3°=640−140.7=499 t·m ⇒wb=77\Rightarrow w_b = 77⇒wb​=77 t of seawater in the starboard wing tank (low tank: KG improves slightly). The anti-heeling system must transfer this mass in step with the slew; check also the heel after a sudden loss of the load with 77 t of ballast still on the opposite side: tan⁡θ=499/(6314×0.70)=0.113⇒6.4°\tan\theta = 499/(6314 \times 0.70) = 0.113 \Rightarrow 6.4°tanθ=499/(6314×0.70)=0.113⇒6.4° — acceptable.

References

IMO IS Code 2008Clause Part B, Ch. 2.9 (Ships engaged in lifting operations), as amended by MSC.415(97)Recommended

Mandatory where the Administration applies Part B to the ship type.

DNV-ST-0378 Standard for offshore and platform lifting appliancesClause Sec. 4 (Design loads — dynamic factors)Mandatory

For the crane structure and foundation; stability is governed by Pt.3 Ch.15 and the IS Code.

Barrass & Derrett (2012)Clause Ch. 26 (Heel due to suspended weights)Textbook