Back to section

NavArch Handbook

Chapter 5 / Section 5.4

Stability at large angles: GZ curves, cross curves (KN)

Why the metacentre is not enough

Beyond about 10° the metacentre moves and GZ=GMsin⁡φGZ = GM\sin\varphiGZ=GMsinφ no longer holds; deck-edge immersion, bilge emergence, superstructure and watertight deckhouses change the shape of the immersed volume. Stability at large angles is described by the curve of statical stability — GZGZGZ against heel angle φ\varphiφ — for each loading condition.

Cross curves of stability (KN curves)

For a given hull, the righting lever depends on displacement and on KGKGKG. To separate the hull geometry from the loading, the designer computes, for a series of displacements and heel angles, the lever KNKNKN: the horizontal distance from the keel point KKK to the vertical through the heeled centre of buoyancy. Then for any KGKGKG:

GZ(φ)=KN(φ)−KGsin⁡φGZ(\varphi) = KN(\varphi) - KG\sin\varphiGZ(φ)=KN(φ)−KGsinφ

KNKNKN values are tabulated or plotted against displacement for φ\varphiφ = 10°, 20°, …, 90° (sometimes 5°, 12°, 15°, 60°, 75° are added). Older booklets give SZSZSZ curves for an assumed pole SSS at height KSKSKS: GZ=SZ−(KG−KS)sin⁡φGZ = SZ - (KG - KS)\sin\varphiGZ=SZ−(KG−KS)sinφ.

Free trim vs fixed trim

Cross curves must be computed with the ship free to trim at each heel angle (the ship trims as she heels, especially with large aft superstructures or trawl decks). Fixed-trim KN values can overstate GZ by several centimetres.

Features of the GZ curve

  1. Initial slope — at the origin the slope equals GMGMGM: the tangent at φ=0\varphi = 0φ=0 reaches the value GMGMGM at φ=1\varphi = 1φ=1 rad (57.3°). This is the standard construction check.
  2. Deck-edge immersion — a point of inflexion; beyond it the curve flattens.
  3. Maximum GZGZGZ and its angle φmax⁡\varphi_{\max}φmax​.
  4. Range of stability — the angle φv\varphi_vφv​ at which GZGZGZ returns to zero (angle of vanishing stability). Practically the range is cut at the downflooding angle φf\varphi_fφf​ at which the first non-weathertight opening immerses.
  5. Watertight superstructures and deckhouses (per IS Code Part B Ch. 3.1) may be included in the buoyant volume and increase GZGZGZ and the range.

Effect of KG and of a transverse shift of G

  • A higher KGKGKG reduces GZGZGZ everywhere by δKGsin⁡φ\delta KG\sin\varphiδKGsinφ (the "KGsin⁡φKG\sin\varphiKGsinφ curve").
  • A transverse offset TCGTCGTCG reduces GZGZGZ by TCGcos⁡φTCG\cos\varphiTCGcosφ and produces a static list where the curves intersect.

Heeling moment curves

External heeling moments (wind, towline, crane, crowding, turning) are plotted as heeling levers lh=Mh/(Δg)l_h = M_h/(\Delta g)lh​=Mh​/(Δg) on the same diagram. The static heel is where GZ=lhGZ = l_hGZ=lh​; the residual area between the curves is used in the dynamic criteria (Section 5.5, 5.7).

Formulas

01Righting lever from KN
GZ(φ)=KN(φ)−KGsin⁡φGZ(\varphi) = KN(\varphi) - KG\sin\varphiGZ(φ)=KN(φ)−KGsinφ
SymbolDescriptionUnit
KNKNKNCross-curve lever (keel to vertical through heeled B)m
KGKGKGHeight of centre of gravity (fluid, i.e. including free surface correction)m

Result unit m

02Righting lever with transverse offset of G
GZ(φ)=KN(φ)−KGsin⁡φ−TCGcos⁡φGZ(\varphi) = KN(\varphi) - KG\sin\varphi - TCG\cos\varphiGZ(φ)=KN(φ)−KGsinφ−TCGcosφ
SymbolDescriptionUnit
TCGTCGTCGTransverse offset of G from centreline towards the heeled sidem

Result unit m

03Initial slope check
dGZdφ∣φ=0=GM(φ in rad)\left.\frac{dGZ}{d\varphi}\right|_{\varphi=0} = GM \quad (\varphi\ \text{in rad})dφdGZ​​φ=0​=GM(φ in rad)

Result unit m/rad

04Heeling lever from a heeling moment
lh=MhΔ gl_h = \frac{M_h}{\Delta\, g}lh​=ΔgMh​​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
lhl_hlh​Heeling leverm
MhM_hMh​Heeling momentkN·m
Δ\DeltaΔDisplacementt

Result unit m

If M_h is in t·m, omit g.

05Heeling lever for a turning ship (IS Code Part B Ch. 3.1.2 form)
lturn=0.200 V02LWL(KG−d2)l_{\text{turn}} = 0.200\,\frac{V_0^2}{L_{WL}}\left(KG - \frac{d}{2}\right)lturn​=0.200LWL​V02​​(KG−2d​)
SymbolDescriptionUnit
V0V_0V0​Service speedm/s
LWLL_{WL}LWL​Waterline lengthm
dddMean draughtm

Result unit m

Passenger ships (IS Code Part B 3.1.2) — heel not to exceed 10°.

Tables

Cross curves (KN) of the example vessel at Δ = 6314 t (free to trim) — illustrative

Heel φ\varphiφ [°]sin⁡φ\sin\varphisinφKNKNKN [m]
100.17361.045
200.34202.110
300.50003.125
400.64283.930
500.76604.490
600.86604.840
700.93975.000
Source: Illustrative values consistent with KM_T = 5.98 m and BM_T = 3.14 m, deck edge immersing at about 27°. Not a real vessel.

Examples

#01

GZ curve of the example vessel from KN values

Worked example

Problem

Using the KN table above and a fluid KGf=5.28KG_f = 5.28KGf​=5.28 m (solid 5.21 m plus free surface correction 0.07 m), compute the GZ curve, the maximum GZ and its angle, and estimate the range of stability.

Solution

GZ=KN−5.28sin⁡φGZ = KN - 5.28\sin\varphiGZ=KN−5.28sinφ:

φ\varphiφKNKNKNKGfsin⁡φKG_f\sin\varphiKGf​sinφGZGZGZ [m]
0000
101.0450.9170.128
202.1101.8060.304
303.1252.6400.485
403.9303.3940.536
504.4904.0440.446
604.8404.5720.268
705.0004.9620.038

Initial slope check: GMf=5.98−5.28=0.70GM_f = 5.98 - 5.28 = 0.70GMf​=5.98−5.28=0.70 m; GZ10°≈0.70×0.1745=0.122GZ_{10°} \approx 0.70 \times 0.1745 = 0.122GZ10°​≈0.70×0.1745=0.122 m vs 0.128 m computed — consistent (the small excess is the wall-sided 12BMtan⁡2φ\tfrac{1}{2}BM\tan^2\varphi21​BMtan2φ term).

Maximum GZ ≈ 0.54 m at about 40° (≥ 25° required). GZ reaches zero at about 71°, so the range of statical stability is ≈ 71°; if the downflooding angle is 55°, the usable range is cut there.

References

IMO IS Code 2008Clause Part B, Ch. 3.1 (Effect of superstructures, deckhouses and openings on the GZ curve) and Part B Ch. 3.5 (Cross curves)Recommended
Rawson & Tupper (2001)Clause Vol. 1, Ch. 4 (Stability at large angles, cross curves)Textbook
Barrass & Derrett (2012)Clause Ch. 17–19 (Curves of statical stability, KN cross curves)Textbook