NavArchHandbook0 ch

No chapters yet.

Engineering toolsIndex of symbolsGlossaryReferences
NavArchHandbook
NavArchHandbook
↵
BookmarksTools
Home›2. Mechanics & Strength of Materials›2.11 Fatigue basics: S–N curves, stress ranges, Miner's rule

Chapter 2 / Section 2.11

Fatigue basics: S–N curves, stress ranges, Miner's rule

Print this section

The phenomenon

Repeated stress cycles well below yield initiate and grow cracks at stress concentrations — weld toes, cut-outs, bracket toes, pipe penetrations. Ship structures see 10710^7107–10810^8108 wave-induced cycles in 25 years plus machinery vibration cycles; cranes and winches see load cycles per lift. Fatigue, not static strength, governs most structural repairs in service.

Stress range and cycles

The governing quantity is the stress range Δσ=σmax⁡−σmin⁡\Delta\sigma = \sigma_{\max} - \sigma_{\min}Δσ=σmax​−σmin​ of each cycle (not the maximum stress). A variable-amplitude history is reduced to a histogram of ranges by rainflow counting; for ships, the long-term distribution of wave-induced stress ranges is often represented by a two-parameter Weibull distribution (DNV-CG-0129).

S–N curves

Fatigue life NNN (cycles to failure) at constant stress range Δσ\Delta\sigmaΔσ:

log⁡N=log⁡aˉ−mlog⁡Δσ⇔N=aˉ Δσ−m\log N = \log \bar a - m \log \Delta\sigma \qquad\Leftrightarrow\qquad N = \bar a\,\Delta\sigma^{-m}logN=logaˉ−mlogΔσ⇔N=aˉΔσ−m

aˉ\bar aaˉ and mmm depend on the detail category (geometry of the weld detail), the environment (air, seawater with cathodic protection, free corrosion) and the stress approach (nominal or hot-spot). DNV-RP-C203 gives bilinear curves: slope m1=3m_1 = 3m1​=3 up to N=107N = 10^7N=107 cycles, then m2=5m_2 = 5m2​=5 (in air); in seawater with cathodic protection the first branch is steeper-lived (lower aˉ\bar aaˉ) and in free corrosion there is no change of slope. The curves are mean-minus-two-standard-deviations (97.7 % survival).

Detail categories (nominal stress approach, RP-C203 Appendix A)

From B1 (plain plate, machined edges) through C, D (transverse butt welds, well-made), E, F, F1, F3 (attachments, fillet welds of increasing severity), G, W1–W3 (load-carrying fillet welds, weld throat). The table gives the air-curve constants for the most used categories. The hot-spot approach uses the D curve with the structural hot-spot stress from a fine-mesh FE model (t×tt \times tt×t elements, read-out at 0.5t0.5t0.5t and 1.5t1.5t1.5t — RP-C203 Sec. 4).

Thickness effect

For plates thicker than the reference tref=25t_{\text{ref}} = 25tref​=25 mm the fatigue strength is reduced: Δσ\Delta\sigmaΔσ is multiplied by (t/tref)k(t/t_{\text{ref}})^k(t/tref​)k with kkk from the category (0.20 for D, 0.25 for F–W).

Mean stress

Welded joints: residual stresses of yield magnitude mean that the full range is damaging regardless of the mean stress — no correction. Base material and post-weld-treated details: a reduction factor applies when part of the cycle is compressive (RP-C203 Sec. 2.5, factor fmf_mfm​: full range when fully tensile, 0.6 × range when fully compressive, linear in between).

Miner's rule (linear damage accumulation)

For kkk blocks of nin_ini​ cycles at range Δσi\Delta\sigma_iΔσi​ with lives NiN_iNi​:

D=∑i=1kniNi≤ηD = \sum_{i=1}^{k}\frac{n_i}{N_i} \le \etaD=i=1∑k​Ni​ni​​≤η

Failure is predicted at D=1D = 1D=1; the design criterion uses η=1/DFF\eta = 1/DFFη=1/DFF with a design fatigue factor DFF between 1 and 3 (or more) depending on accessibility for inspection and consequence of failure (DNV-OS-C101 for offshore units; ship rules work with a 25-year design life at a specified probability level — DNV Rules Pt.3 Ch.9 and DNV-CG-0129).

Design against fatigue

  1. Avoid: soft toes on brackets, generous radii at cut-outs, no attachments to highly stressed flanges, full-penetration welds in load-carrying joints, grinding of weld toes (allows a higher category or a factor on life).
  2. Compute: stress range spectrum → category → damage.
  3. Inspect: details with DFF = 1 must be inspectable.

Formulas

01S–N curve
log⁡10N=log⁡10aˉ−m log⁡10Δσ⇔N=aˉ Δσ−m\log_{10} N = \log_{10}\bar a - m\,\log_{10}\Delta\sigma \qquad\Leftrightarrow\qquad N = \bar a\,\Delta\sigma^{-m}log10​N=log10​aˉ−mlog10​Δσ⇔N=aˉΔσ−m
SymbolDescriptionUnit
NNNNumber of cycles to failure-
Δσ\Delta\sigmaΔσStress rangeMPa
aˉ\bar aaˉS–N curve intercept (category and environment dependent)MPa^m
mmmNegative inverse slope (3 or 5 for welded steel in air)-

Result unit cycles

02Bilinear S–N curve (RP-C203 air)
N={aˉ1 Δσ−3N≤107 (Δσ≥Δσ107)aˉ2 Δσ−5N>107N = \begin{cases} \bar a_1\,\Delta\sigma^{-3} & N \le 10^7 \ (\Delta\sigma \ge \Delta\sigma_{10^7}) \\ \bar a_2\,\Delta\sigma^{-5} & N > 10^7 \end{cases}N={aˉ1​Δσ−3aˉ2​Δσ−5​N≤107 (Δσ≥Δσ107​)N>107​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
Δσ107\Delta\sigma_{10^7}Δσ107​Stress range at the knee (10⁷ cycles), e.g. 52.63 MPa for DMPa

Result unit cycles

03Thickness correction
Δσeff=Δσ(ttref)k,tref=25 mm,t>tref\Delta\sigma_{\text{eff}} = \Delta\sigma\left(\frac{t}{t_{\text{ref}}}\right)^{k}, \qquad t_{\text{ref}} = 25\ \text{mm}, \quad t > t_{\text{ref}}Δσeff​=Δσ(tref​t​)k,tref​=25 mm,t>tref​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
kkkThickness exponent (0 for B1/B2; 0.20 for D, E; 0.25 for F–W)-

Result unit MPa

04Miner's rule
D=∑i=1kniNi=∑iniaˉ Δσim≤1DFFD = \sum_{i=1}^{k}\frac{n_i}{N_i} = \sum_i \frac{n_i}{\bar a}\,\Delta\sigma_i^{m} \le \frac{1}{DFF}D=i=1∑k​Ni​ni​​=i∑​aˉni​​Δσim​≤DFF1​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
nin_ini​Number of cycles in block i-
NiN_iNi​Cycles to failure at range Δσ_i-
DFFDFFDFFDesign fatigue factor (1–3 typical; up to 10 for non-inspectable critical offshore details)-

Result unit -

05Hot-spot stress from FE read-out points
σhs=1.67 σ0.5t−0.67 σ1.5t\sigma_{hs} = 1.67\,\sigma_{0.5t} - 0.67\,\sigma_{1.5t}σhs​=1.67σ0.5t​−0.67σ1.5t​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
σ0.5t,σ1.5t\sigma_{0.5t}, \sigma_{1.5t}σ0.5t​,σ1.5t​Surface stresses read at 0.5t and 1.5t from the weld toe (linear extrapolation)MPa

Result unit MPa

DNV-RP-C203 Sec. 4; use the D curve with hot-spot stress.

06Mean stress reduction for base material (RP-C203 form)
Δσred=fm Δσ,fm=σt+0.6 σcσt+σc\Delta\sigma_{\text{red}} = f_m\,\Delta\sigma, \qquad f_m = \frac{\sigma_t + 0.6\,\sigma_c}{\sigma_t + \sigma_c}Δσred​=fm​Δσ,fm​=σt​+σc​σt​+0.6σc​​
SymbolDescriptionUnit
σt\sigma_tσt​Tensile part of the stress rangeMPa
σc\sigma_cσc​Compressive part of the stress range (absolute value)MPa

Result unit MPa

Not for as-welded joints (residual stresses). Confirm the current form in RP-C203 Sec. 2.5.

Tables

DNV-RP-C203 S–N curves in air for welded steel (selected detail categories)

Categorym1m_1m1​log⁡10aˉ1\log_{10}\bar a_1log10​aˉ1​ (N ≤ 10⁷)m2m_2m2​log⁡10aˉ2\log_{10}\bar a_2log10​aˉ2​ (N > 10⁷)Range at 10⁷ cycles [MPa]Thickness exponent kkkTypical detail
B1415.117517.146106.970Plain plate, machined edges, no welds
C312.592516.32073.100.05Transverse butt weld ground flush, NDT
C1312.449516.08165.500.10Transverse butt weld, as welded, toe angle ≤ 30°
D312.164515.60652.630.20Transverse butt weld as welded; **hot-spot curve**
E312.010515.35046.780.20Butt weld on backing; fillet-welded attachment ≤ 150 mm along stress
F311.855515.09141.520.25Attachment > 150 mm; cruciform full-penetration
F1311.699514.83236.840.25Fillet-welded cruciform / bracket toe with gap
F3311.546514.57632.750.25Partial penetration cruciform; cover plate ends
G311.398514.33029.240.25Attachment on edge; load-carrying fillet toe
W3310.970513.61721.050.25Fillet weld throat (shear on weld)
Source: DNV-RP-C203 Fatigue design of offshore steel structures, Table 2-1 (S–N curves in air) and Appendix A (detail categories). Edition 2019 or later — verify the constants against the edition in force before use; seawater with cathodic protection and free-corrosion curves differ.

Design fatigue factors (indicative)

SituationDFFSource
Accessible for inspection and repair, in dry or above splash zone, failure not critical1.0DNV-OS-C101 (offshore)
Accessible, below splash zone / wet2.0DNV-OS-C101
Not accessible for inspection, or failure critical3.0DNV-OS-C101
Non-inspectable, substantial consequence (some offshore cases)up to 10DNV-OS-C101 / project specification
Ship hull details (class rules)Design life 25 years at the rule probability level; equivalent to DFF ≈ 1 with conservative load spectrumDNV Rules Pt.3 Ch.9; DNV-CG-0129
Source: DNV-OS-C101 Design of offshore steel structures, general (LRFD method) — fatigue section; DNV-CG-0129 Fatigue assessment of ship structures. Confirm editions.

Examples

#01

Miner damage of a bracket toe under two load blocks

Worked example

Problem

A deck crane pedestal bracket toe (as-welded, fillet, category F1, plate 20 mm) sees during 25 years: block 1 — 2.0 × 10⁶ cycles at a hot-spot/nominal stress range of 60 MPa (lifting operations); block 2 — 1.0 × 10⁷ cycles at 40 MPa (wave-induced hull girder plus deck vibration). Compute the fatigue damage with the F1 air curve and compare with DFF = 2 (accessible, splash-zone deck).

Solution

Plate 20 mm < 25 mm → no thickness penalty.

Block 1: Δσ=60\Delta\sigma = 60Δσ=60 MPa > 36.84 (knee) → m=3m = 3m=3: N1=1011.699/603=5.000×1011/216 000=2.31×106N_1 = 10^{11.699}/60^3 = 5.000 \times 10^{11}/216\,000 = 2.31 \times 10^6N1​=1011.699/603=5.000×1011/216000=2.31×106. D1=2.0×106/2.31×106=0.864D_1 = 2.0 \times 10^6/2.31 \times 10^6 = 0.864D1​=2.0×106/2.31×106=0.864.

Block 2: Δσ=40\Delta\sigma = 40Δσ=40 MPa > 36.84 → still m=3m = 3m=3: N2=5.000×1011/64 000=7.81×106N_2 = 5.000 \times 10^{11}/64\,000 = 7.81 \times 10^6N2​=5.000×1011/64000=7.81×106. D2=1.0×107/7.81×106=1.280D_2 = 1.0 \times 10^7/7.81 \times 10^6 = 1.280D2​=1.0×107/7.81×106=1.280.

Total D=2.14>1/DFF=0.5D = 2.14 > 1/DFF = 0.5D=2.14>1/DFF=0.5 — fails by a factor of more than 4.

With the toe ground and a full-penetration weld the detail might be classed E (log⁡aˉ1=12.010\log\bar a_1 = 12.010logaˉ1​=12.010, aˉ1=1.023×1012\bar a_1 = 1.023 \times 10^{12}aˉ1​=1.023×1012): N1=4.74×106N_1 = 4.74 \times 10^6N1​=4.74×106, D1=0.42D_1 = 0.42D1​=0.42; N2=1.60×107N_2 = 1.60 \times 10^7N2​=1.60×107 → above the knee? No: at 40 MPa the E-curve knee is 46.78 MPa, so 40 MPa lies on the m=5m = 5m=5 branch: N2=1015.350/405=2.239×1015/1.024×108=2.19×107N_2 = 10^{15.350}/40^5 = 2.239 \times 10^{15}/1.024 \times 10^8 = 2.19 \times 10^7N2​=1015.350/405=2.239×1015/1.024×108=2.19×107, D2=0.46D_2 = 0.46D2​=0.46; total D=0.88D = 0.88D=0.88 — still above 0.5. The bracket must be redesigned (soft toe, larger radius, thicker insert to reduce the stress range by ~25 %: damage scales with Δσ3\Delta\sigma^3Δσ3, so a 25 % reduction gives D≈0.37D \approx 0.37D≈0.37 ✓). This is the typical outcome: fatigue at pedestal and winch foundations is governed by detail design, not by plate thickness.

References

DNV-RP-C203 Fatigue design of offshore steel structuresClause Sec. 2 (Fatigue analysis based on S–N data), Sec. 4 (Hot-spot stress by FE), Appendix A (Classification of structural details)Recommended

Free download (registration) from dnv.com. Confirm edition.

DNV-CG-0129 Fatigue assessment of ship structuresClause Sec. 2–4 (Fatigue loads, long-term distribution, S–N curves for ships)Recommended

Referenced by DNV Rules Pt.3 Ch.9.

Hughes & Paik, Ship Structural Analysis and Design (SNAME, 2010)Clause Ch. 15 (Fatigue of ship structures)Textbook
Maddox, S.J., Fatigue Strength of Welded Structures, 2nd ed. (1991)Clause Ch. 2–4 (S–N approach, detail classification, variable amplitude)Textbook
Previous · 2.10Column and plate bucklingNext · 2.12Allowable stresses and safety factors in rule-based design

Version 2 · last updated 19 Nov 2026 · Editor

On this page

  • The phenomenon
  • Stress range and cycles
  • S–N curves
  • Detail categories (nominal stress approach, RP-C203 Appendix A)
  • Thickness effect
  • Mean stress
  • Miner's rule (linear damage accumulation)
  • Design against fatigue
  • Formulas
  • Tables
  • Examples
  • References

Applicable standards

  • DNV-RP-C203 Fatigue design of offshore steel structures

    Sec. 2 (Fatigue analysis based on S–N data), Sec. 4 (Hot-spot stress by FE), Appendix A (Classification of structural details)

  • DNV-CG-0129 Fatigue assessment of ship structures

    Sec. 2–4 (Fatigue loads, long-term distribution, S–N curves for ships)

  • Hughes & Paik, Ship Structural Analysis and Design (SNAME, 2010)

    Ch. 15 (Fatigue of ship structures)

  • Maddox, S.J., Fatigue Strength of Welded Structures, 2nd ed. (1991)

    Ch. 2–4 (S–N approach, detail classification, variable amplitude)

NavArch Handbook·About & disclaimerFeedbackBookmarks© Jadrija Maritime j.d.o.o.